Our associate shopping editor is picky when it comes to pillows, to say the least—but Cozy Earth’s silk-filled option won her over.

And if you have other accent pillows with damaged covers, this is also a great way to repurpose their stuffing. Just rip them open and use the loose fill to add volume to a fresh pillow.

But others say that after removing some stuffing, it decreased their neck pain. For another pillow with natural materials, consider the Sobakawa Buckwheat Pillow. Chelsea Logan has been using the ...